Don't Trust Your Senses, They Can Deceive You!

Don’t Trust Your Senses, They Can Deceive You!

Written By: Kevin Watson

10th April 2015

Can you really trust your senses when deciding to trust other people?

The other day I was researching material on communication for a leadership programme I’m about to launch with a well-known retailer and I stumbled across this illusion that made me question everything I thought I knew about verbal and non-verbal cues.

The McGurk Effect, first described by psychologist Harry McGurk, tricks your brain into hearing things that haven’t actually been said.

Effectively, non-verbal cues and the way things are said to determine what is communicated. In other words, when our eyes tell us one thing and our ears another, the eyes have it!

We literally hear what our eyes tell us.

It works because people think they hear most words.

In fact, we rely on our eyes to hear words, as much as our ears!

So, when you add something such as text, suggesting to the eye (and then to the ears) what should be heard, then the text wins the day. Given ambiguous inputs, the eye will overrule the ear and substitute its judgment.

On-screen, if you are given a line of text telling you what the speaker is saying you will hear the speaker saying it, even if he is not, in fact, saying it at all.

This was demonstrated in the run up to the US presidential election, when MSNBC made a story out of a crowd chanting “Ryan” instead of “Romney”, questioning whether Mitt Romney was generating sufficient support.

It turns out they were providing misleading visual cues, by adding the word Ryan to the screen and using the McGurk Effect!

It’s an interesting demonstration of suggestibility and has set me wondering where this may play out in our everyday lives.

Can you really trust your senses when meeting people?

Coaching Works

Download your free copy of this illustrated eBook, with quotes from coaches around the world in response to the question: how do you know when coaching works?


Coaching Conversations

articles, videos and resources to further the conversation about coaching

Coaching Development

articles, videos and exercises to help you develop your own coaching skills

Leadership Coaching

articles and resources to help develop your leadership practice

Team Coaching

articles and resources to help create and maintain teams and high-performance teamworking

Coaching News

articles, videos and resources from around the globe curated for you to enjoy

You May Also Like:

How Will You Reflect On Your Day?

How Will You Reflect On Your Day?

One of the great achievements coaching is credited for is the emergence of reflecting as a discipline. Use the WHAT, SO WHAT, NOW WHAT to help you reflect and grow.

What Are You Doing About Your Blind Spot?

What Are You Doing About Your Blind Spot?

You may have heard of the Johari Window, a simple and useful tool for illustrating and improving self-awareness. It’s especially relevant today, placing emphasis on building empathy, collaboration, inter-team development and interpersonal development.


Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Share This